Why the World Bank’s poverty estimate for India invites scrutiny
Pulapre Balakrishnan and Aman Raj
The World Bank recently released estimates of poverty in India, pegging “extreme poverty” at 2.6 percent (‘India Poverty and Equity Brief: October 2026’). If true that would be good news, as it implies high levels of economic deprivation are now a thing of the past. We argue that such a conclusion would be premature.
The World Bank poverty estimate is a headcount ratio, i.e, the ratio of the number of poor to the population. The number of poor is estimated by applying a poverty line to data reported in the NSS’s Household Consumption Expenditure Survey for 2023-24 (HCES). The poverty line translated into goods represents the minimum acceptable level of consumption, below which an individual is deemed poor. The set of goods, and their prices, the World Bank considers when it constructed its poverty line for India is not mentioned in the report. We do know though that the consumption data comes from the HCES. The Survey is a rich source of consumption across the population, revealing granular information on the standard of living of the population, which can be used to assess a headcount poverty estimate, as we demonstrate.
In 2025 we had in these pages proposed a simple measure of the standard of living in India. Termed the ‘thali index’ it measures the number of thalis an individual can afford to buy based on the monthly per capita expenditure on food that is reported in the HCES. Why did we choose the thali as the metric? The thali is a metaphor for a complete meal, combining protein, carbohydrates and minerals. It is a unit of food consumption that Indians culturally relate to as both nutritious and satisfying. A thali, then, is the “square” meal of old English usage. To measure the standard of living of Indians based on the thali index we would need to apply a price to the consumption expenditure reported. We have adopted Rs. 30 as the price of a thali, being the cost of a home-cooked vegetarian thali as estimated by CRISIL for the year 2023-24. We choose a home-cooked vegetarian thali as it is the cheapest. Anyone with a sense of the streets would know that a thali with meat or fish eaten in the cheapest establishments would cost much more. Applying the thali index to the data on consumption across expenditure groups we found that upto 50 percent of rural Indians and 20 percent of urban Indians cannot afford two thali meals a day. Imputing the value of the subsidised food, which the WB report refers to as a factor affecting poverty, lowers this percentage to 40 percent and 10 percent, respectively. This implies that approximately 30 percent of the Indian population cannot afford two square meals day, making it difficult to stomach an estimate of less than 3 percent for poverty in India.
Note that the World Bank’s estimate and ours come from the same source, namely, the HCES. The difference is that the Bank uses a poverty line to measure income poverty while we are going by the directly observable data on the food consumption level. If two thali meals per day is considered the minimum acceptable food consumption, our findings imply levels of extreme poverty higher than the World Bank’s estimate. The implication of our finding is that the World Bank must rethink the poverty line that it uses for India. The point is that even if the income at its currently-used poverty line is more than sufficient to enable two thalis a day per person there are several items of expenditure that must be met by a household to earn a livelihood, maintain good health and educate their young. We can think of rent, medicines and school fees. It is likely that these expenses are met first, so as to ensure survival, reducing food to the status of a residual item of consumption. If we accept the criterion of a minimum level of food consumption for an individual to be counted as non-poor then the chosen poverty line must reflect this feature. If 30 percent of the population does not have access to two square meals a day, surely we cannot hold that less than 3 percent of the population is poor. Our argument has been made with respect to the World Bank’s measure of income poverty but carries over to the Multi-dimensional Poverty Index of the UNDP to the extent that it relies on the Bank’s poverty line.
The latest poverty estimates from the World Bank could create complacency in economic policy-making, for if extreme poverty is almost non-existent policies are needed to remedy it. But our finding of a low level of food consumption for a significant section of Indians imparts an urgency to it. The level of food consumption is directly affected by food prices, and controlling the price of food is central to safeguarding well-being of the population. Right now, we are experiencing a surge in food-price inflation. Quite unusually, between January and September of this year it has risen in every month, trebling over this period. This means that prices are not just continuously rising but the rise in prices is accelerating. An urgent review of the policies to control food price inflation is warranted. Food price inflation can only be controlled by managing food supply, in particular by producing more food at a steady price. This requires a growing agricultural productivity, for as the population grows so will the demand for food.
Balakrishnan is an honorary visiting professor of the Centre for Development Studies, Thiruvananthapuram and Raj is a PhD student of Shiv Nadar University, New Delhi